FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $99 USD! 😻

✨ All jewelry - Buy 2, Get 3rd 50% Off! ✨

Cart

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping Spend $99 more for free shipping

Your cart is empty.

Continue browsing

Estimate shipping

Country

Province

Postal/Zip Code

Shipping & taxes calculated at checkout

Cat Toys

26 products

Filter

All collections All collections

Beds

Cat Toys

Catnip Toys

Dog Toys

Easter

For Cats

For Dogs

Jewelry

Made in USA

Scratchers

St. Patrick's Day

Sterling Silver

Valentine's Day

Handmade caterpillar kicker toys in various colors and patterns, stuffed with US grown, farm fresh catnip. Made in USA.

"Cat"erpillars Kicker Catnip Toy

Sold Out

Handmade squirrel kicker toys in various colors and patterns with feather tails. Each one is stuffed with US grown, farm fresh catnip. Made in USA.

Squirrels Kicker Catnip Feather Toy

Sold Out

Handmade square shaped toys in various colors and patterns, stuffed with US grown, farm fresh catnip. Made in USA.

Kittles Catnip Cat Toy

Fleece taco cat toy filled with organic catnip.

Tabby's Taco Catnip Toy

Fleece pizza cat toy filled with organic catnip.

Purrsian Pizza Catnip Toy

Fleece calico cookie cat toy filled with organic catnip.

Calico Cookie Catnip Toy

Fleece heart cat toys filled with organic catnip.

Hissy Hearts Catnip Toy

Fleece fortune cookie cat toy filled with organic catnip.

Furry Fortune Cookie Catnip Toy

Sea Creature Felted Merino Wool Cat Toy

4 colors available

Organic wool balls in pastel hues.

Pastel "Fairy Dust" Felted Wool Balls

6 colors available

Organic wool stingray cat toys in green, yellow and orange.

Spotty the Stingray Felted Wool Cat Toy

3 colors available

Organic wool lion cat and dog toy.

Ronnie the Lion Felted Wool Pet Toy

Organic wool ladybug cat toy.

Gina the Ladybug Felted Wool Cat Toy

Organic wool bee cat toy.

Berta the Honeybee Felted Wool Cat Toy

Organic wool spring cat toys in rainbow, purple, blue and neutral.

Spring Felted Wool Cat Toy

4 colors available

Organic wool caterpillar cat toy in neutral tones (brown, white, & charcoal). Has bell at the end of it's tail.

Brownie Kat the Caterpillar Felted Wool Cat Toy

Organic wool caterpillar cat toy in pastel tones (purple, white, blue, pink & yellow). Has bell at the end of its tail.

Candy Kat the Caterpillar Felted Wool Cat Toy

Organic wool caterpillar cat toy in red, blue & green tones. Has bell at the end of its tail.

Hungry Kat the Caterpillar Felted Wool Cat Toy

Sold Out

Organic wool caterpillar cat toy in vibrant tones (orange, hot pink & lemon yellow). Has bell at the end of its tail.

Summer Kat the Caterpillar Felted Wool Cat Toy

Rainbow wool cat toys with white cloud accents.

Rainbow Felted Wool Cat Toy

Three anthropomorphic shamrocks in different shades of green, made of wool.

Shamrock Felted Wool Cat Toy

Green and white plaid fleece catnip kicker toy with looped trim.

St. Patrick's Day Celtic Kicker Catnip Toy

A grouping of six easter bunny felted wool cat toys.

Easter Bunny Felted Wool Cat Toy

6 colors available

Grouping of orange carrot felted wool cat toys.

Orange Carrot Felted Wool Cat Toy

Sold Out

Grouping of pink carrot felted wool cat toys.

Pink Carrot Felted Wool Cat Toy

Fleece tie-die rabbit face cat toy filled with organic catnip.

Hare Ball Catnip Toy

Sold Out

© It Started With a Kitten 2024 All Rights Reserved

DMCA.com Protection Status